| Type | Date | Mint | Grade | | | Price | Comments | Photo | Buy |
| $5 | 1881 | | ICG | AU | 58 | $550 | Orange-peel surfaces | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1885 | | ICG | AU | 58 | $550 | Wiped, but much original luster | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1886 | | ICG | AU | 58 | $550 | | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1886 | S | ICG | MS | 60 | $550 | 6 to 9 O'clock planchet roughness | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1893 | | ICG | AU | 58 | $525 | lightly cleaned | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1893 | | ICG | MS | 60 | $525 | lightly cleaned; nice coin | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1893 | S | ANACS | AU | 58 | $495 | Lightly wiped on L obv | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1896 | | NGC | MS | 64 | $1895 | Mintage: 59,063; bright and lustrous | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1909 | D | NGC | MS | 64 | $3795 | Sharply struck, frosty luster; some light carbon | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1910 | | NGC | AU | 58 | $525 | Well struck | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1913 | | NGC | AU | 58 | $525 | well struck, subdued luster | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1913 | S | ICG | MS | 62 | $4295 | Nice strike, light gold color | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1914 | | NCS | AU | 55 | $495 | lightly cleaned; flat luster | fr/bk | buy |
| $5 | 1914 | | PCGS | MS | 64 | $3795 | Rich color, near gem | fr/bk | buy |
